Green shoots in Spain’s real estate sector?
Foreign nationals taking advantage of falling costs are descending on the 'costas'
All is not lost: they say that the end of the property crisis is coming from the East, where Spain offers sunny weather, good services, excellent communications and now, cheap housing too. This has become a land of opportunity for a certain type of foreign client with money in their pockets. Mortgage loans may have dried out, but that does not matter; these customers pay in cash.
The Mediterranean region is producing a new model of real estate opportunity: the two-bedroom apartment for 60,000 euros. This is what some banks had been trying to avoid for a long time: demolition prices. But there it is. Reality has moved faster than the government and its bad bank project.
There are two ways of looking at life in the real estate sector. Looking out from the top, on the 19th floor of Madrid's Torre Picasso, the workplace of investment fund consultants, the situation is viewed with a cold, cautious eye: "In the short term, the bad bank will act like the casting-out-nines technique. Things will never be the same," says Rafael Roldán, an executive at Ernst & Young. Or, in other words, big capital has yet to make a move.
But down below, at street level, inside the sales offices, there is a certain degree of optimism. "We're starting to sell again," says Brigitte Castaño, a representative of the realtor Remax in Alicante. Castaño is enthusiastic about the new clients who are coming to the Spanish Mediterranean: a cosmopolitan crowd made up of Russians, Scandinavians, French, and her personal favorite, Belgians. Alicante is also currently witnessing a new trend that is far from anecdotal; the arrival of Algerian clients who purchase homes in the city. Cash-carrying buyers are also showing up further south on Costa del Sol, "where 90 percent of sales are to foreigners," says Leonardo Cromstedt from Marbella.
So are these the signs of green shoots along the Spanish coast?
"This does not constitute a market yet," says a consultant to a foreign bank in an indifferent tone. For the big consulting firms, real business will arrive when the investment funds return. But for now, they are waiting to see what happens. "A 50-percent price discount is not enough, so everything will depend on how the bad bank turns out and how its assets are valued."
According to this expert, who declined to see his name in print, the investment funds are waiting for demolition prices before moving in again. "They are waiting for 70 percent [discounts]."
So the key seems to lie in the demolition prices. Is that what is attracting the Russians, the Belgians, the Germans and the French? Rafael Roldán, of Ersnt & Young, seems to think so: "Deep down, what's going on now is a dress rehearsal for the bad bank. Prices are adjusting to reality. Sales are being conducted. There are investors coming in from abroad who are not contaminated. But it will be important for the government's bad bank to be a success." So while the big clients await news about the bad bank to make their decisions inside their lofty glass offices, the rest of the world is getting a move on.
It might be a moderate move; it might certainly not be causing significant changes to absolute figures, but this market - which is not even a market to some consultants - has a life of its own.
And when you look at the big figures, the real estate sector has been a deserted place for the last five years. The statistics show red numbers year after year. And indicators point to a stubborn cycle of decadence: prices go down, sales drop, real estate agencies and construction companies shut down, cement production dwindles -- and the banks that participated in the game most enthusiastically fall with them.
Those news stories about mayors signing agreements to build thousands of homes have given way to images of local residents camping out to avoid foreclosure. There have been two eviction-related suicides.
It would seem that nobody's buying around here. What's more, it's a safe bet that some of those who bought a property would happily return it to the bank if they could. And yet 356,656 homes changed hands in 2011, according to notary figures. It might seem like a low number compared with the 853,568 sales in 2007 (the last glory year for the sector), but it is a sign that there is a far from insignificant business out there.
A two-bedroom apartment in Benidorm is going for 51,000 euros. An apartment in Empuriabrava costs 75,000 euros. A luxury home near Alicante is available for 120,000 euros. Thousands of ads like these are on display on French real estate websites. On Vivastreet.fr there are 375 ads for homes under the headline Espagne. On Arkadia, the most popular search terms are Andalucía, Torrevieja, Catalogne, Mallorca. And there is a tool that proves that today's prices are truly affordable for the residents of Europe's second-largest economy: the average price of a two-bedroom apartment in Spain is 2,265 euros/m². A year ago it was 2,854 euros/m², a 26-percent drop.
"In the summer, I am hearing more and more French in Guardamar," explains Nieves Martínez, a Spaniard from León who arrived in Paris in the 1960s at age 16 and spent 10 years working as domestic help for a daughter of General De Gaulle's; eventually she was able to buy herself a 120-square-meter apartment in Alicante. "Now I am thinking about giving it to my children and buying myself something cheaper; I have seen some really nice places for 60,000 euros."
In the last few months, the property bust has driven up sales of Spanish properties. France now ranks second on the list of countries that invest the most in Spanish real estate, representing eight percent of all foreign purchases. The Spanish consulate in Paris is currently awarding four power of signature documents, to conduct transactions in Spain, per day.
The situation on the coast is a case in point. There are parts of it where you can sense a contained euphoria from the reports by the property agencies. There is a new kind of buyer: informed clients who show up with money in their pockets and who are not seeking large properties. Typically, these clients are seeking one or two-bedroom apartments for a price as far below 100,000 euros as possible.
"The British are no longer buying on the same scale," explains Castaño.
"The Belgian and Scandinavian markets are doing very well now. They are aware that the market is very low and that the time is right to buy a home. They pay in cash. I have only handled two mortgages this year: a civil guard and a Belgian who was just a bit short of cash. The national market is non-existent," the realtor says.
This vision of reality coincides with that of Leo Cromstedt, a sales representative for the same company in Marbella, who says that 90 percent of his clients are foreigners -- mostly Norwegians and Swedes -- who pay cash. If 4,758 homes were sold in 2004 in Marbella, there were only 2,286 sales in 2011, so prices will not stabilize until sales reach around 3,500 a year, he says.
"Clients have a lot of information thanks to the internet. They know everything that's up for sale. If they find an area they like, they seek everything that's on sale there at the cheapest price. Clients want to be in charge. They look for good pricing and they're not in a hurry."
There are particular cases like Benahavis, a municipality located next to Marbella, where home sales have increased 219 percent in just one year.
What's the secret? Leo Cromstedt explains: "Marbella was more competitive for the same prices and for three years they sold nothing. So they knocked down their prices, by as much as 70 percent. And the sale boom began."
Similar opinions and statistics show up on other parts of the coast. In Almería there have been Russian buyers ever since the first charter flights to Moscow were inaugurated. In Murcia and Alicante, realtors are surprised at all the French buyers. The Costa Dorada is a Russian bastion. Figures provided by the General Council of Notaries confirm these impressions: in 2007, only 1.1 percent of buyers were Russian, compared with eight percent now. French buyers increased from 1.6 percent to 8.4 percent.
And the Germans? They are buying more holiday homes than ever, but they would rather do so in their own country. Half their holiday properties are in Germany, followed by Spain (11.3 percent). According to a study by the specialized real estate agencies Fewo Direkt and Engel & Völkers, the percentage of holiday homes in Spain has risen one point in three years. The island of Mallorca now contains three percent of Germans' holiday homes, ranking third after the Austrian region of Tyrol and the US state of Florida.
Stefan Lange, a specialist in Spanish properties, explained last week to Berliner Morgenpost that the crisis has sunk prices in regions that are highly appreciated by German buyers. He is talking about 50-square-meter homes that can be had for as little as 50,000 euros. But Lange also notes that some Germans are returning home - people like the Jochens, a retired couple who are moving back out of fears that the cutbacks in the Catalan healthcare system will endanger their own medical treatments.
But one of the most striking trends in the real estate market is taking place in Alicante, which has become a second home for Algerians. Geographical proximity (just 12 hours away by sea) and historical trade routes explain the cordial relations between Algeria and Alicante. But in the last three years, encouraged by falling prices and their own property bubble at home, Algerians have been turning to Alicante as the place to buy their second homes.
"Between 20 percent and 30 percent of the title deeds we register are apartment sales to Algerians," explains a notary in the capital. The realtor Tecnocasa says that since July, 66 percent of their sales in Alicante were to non-EU citizens, and of those, 90 percent were Algerian.
A good number of property agencies coincide in their profile of the average buyer from the Maghreb: male, mid-to-high purchasing power, often working in a liberal profession, and seeking cheap apartments between 40,000 and 80,000 euros. Five years ago, such a search would have been fruitless. Algerians are buying properties in Alicante's first suburban development and in the more economical neighborhoods north of the city; around Plaza Orán and Argel are the main enclaves. Naturally, they pay in cash.
But the most notable clients are the Russians. They come from far away, they are forceful, and there are many of them. According to the Moscow agency Masa International, Spain has become their main purchasing territory, ahead of Bulgaria, which was until now Russians' favorite beach home location.
Moscow alone has 250 agencies selling Spanish properties, and some specialize exclusively in Spain, according to the Russian measurement company GIS (Geoinformatiónnaya Sistema). One of the factors behind this boom is tourism: a million Russians visit Spain each year. Russia is the market that Costa Dorada realtors aim for, such as Europa Dom, 75 percent of whose clients are Russian. "And growing," adds agency director Olga Otero, who is planning to set up showrooms in Russia.
"Banks are seeking collective buyers in Russia who will purchase an entire block as an investment," says Manuel Sosa, secretary of the Tarragona Chamber of Urban Property. The Catalan government has embarked on a hunt for Russian investors for Barcelona World, the region's answer to the EuroVegas casino resort that will finally be built in Madrid. Barcelona World will include six theme parks inspired by different parts of the world, with Russia among them.
Yet all these figures are relative. In absolute terms, 85 percent of home buyers in Spain continue to be Spaniards, a figure that has barely gone down two points in the last few years. But Spanish buyers are as depressed as their economy. And so some experts believe that the arrival of these new clients -- these Central Europeans with their disposable savings -- is the first sign of an end to the crisis. A first green shoot. And an initial warning to the largest real estate agency in Europe, about to be born with its 90 billion euros in assets: the bad bank. The question remains: will it offer demolition prices?
Rosa Biot and Santiago Navarro contributed to this story from Alicante, Juan Gómez from Berlin, Rodrigo Fernández from Moscow and Mercè Pérez Pons from Tarragona.