YPF EXPROPRIATION

Second legal front may open in Repsol’s battle with Argentina

Repsol has to buy Eskenazi YPF stake under 2008 deal

Spanish firm can argue nationalization is force majeure

Repsol, whose YPF unit was nationalized by Argentina this week, agreed in 2008 to buy back the Eskenazi family’s shares in that oil company in the event that Repsol were to lose majority control, Bloomberg reported Friday.

The accord also calls on Repsol, under certain conditions, to take over loans the family used to buy YPF shares. Repsol spokesman Kristian Rix said the agreement is “not applicable” in the context of expropriation.

Repsol would probably try to fight a move by the Eskenazis to enforce the accord by using a so-called force majeure argument, according to two lawyers familiar with the matter who saw the document or were briefed on it. The Eskenazi family’s 25-percent stake in YPF was not nationalized.

Repsol Chairman Antonio Brufau this week called the expropriation illegal and estimated Repsol’s potential loss at 5.7 billion euros. Salvador Gabarró, the chairman of Gas Natural Fenosa, of which Repsol owns 30 percent, on Friday called for a “measured” response from the government to the expropriation.

Repsol would argue that Argentina’s seizure of 51 percent of YPF was an unforeseeable event preventing it from fulfilling its obligation to the Eskenazis, said Tom Ginsburg, a professor of international law at the University of Chicago.

“It’s black-letter law that expropriation by a government would constitute force majeure so long as it was not foreseen or foreseeable by the company,” Ginsburg said. “The Eskenazi family will argue that Argentina had a long history of expropriation, so it should have been foreseeable that a change in ownership could come about through a government takeover.”

Repsol will claim that it did not voluntarily change its ownership stake, so it does not have a duty to pay the Eskenazis, Ginsburg said.

Para poder comentar debes estar registrado en Eskup y haber iniciado sesión

Darse de alta ¿Por qué darse de alta?

Otras noticias

LATIN AMERICA

Mujica to ask Obama for help in anti-smoking dispute

Magdalena Martínez Montevideo

Phillip Morris claims Uruguay is violating bilateral treaty

Accords reached in Venezuelan peace talks

Alfredo Meza Caracas

Opposition agrees to take part in a truth commission

Calm returns to Nicaragua after quake panic

Carlos Salinas Managua

Experts want to determine what sparked the tremors

Venezuelan TV reporter released unharmed

Nairobi Pinto was found unharmed on Monday

Cocaine shipments through Caribbean on the rise

Maye Primera Miami

Smugglers being forced to use alternative routes following crackdowns in Mexico

García Márquez’s health is “delicate,” says family

Juan Diego Quesada Mexico City

Nobel Prize-winning author reportedly receiving palliative care

Mob lynchings in Argentina put moral values in doubt

Beating death of a suspect ignites more mob violence

Lo más visto en...

» Top 50

Webs de PRISA

cerrar ventana