IMMIGRATION

Internment centers not always deportation halfway house

Spain seen flouting European law by locking up migrants it cannot expel

A policeman with immigrants in an internment center in the Canary Islands. / J. MEDINA (REUTERS)

Only half of the illegal immigrants who were confined to one of Spain's nine Immigrant Internment Centers (CIE) last year were eventually deported, the Popular Party spokesman for the Congress Interior Committee, Conrado Escobar, revealed at a conference on Tuesday.

Of the 13,241 people locked up in a CIE in 2011, just 6,825 (51.5 percent) were returned to their country of origin, said Escobar, who was attending a conference organized by the General Council of Spanish Bar Associations (CGAE) to discuss the future of the centers. That means almost 6,500 people were deprived of their freedom without a repatriation ever materializing.

The CGAE says internment of illegal immigrants is not a punishment, but a precautionary measure to guarantee deportation when it seems necessary - according to Supreme Court doctrine, illegal stays should first be punished with a fine. Confinement should only be ordered when there are guarantees that repatriation can be carried out.

Commissioner general for immigration, Emilio Baos, explained that the main problem when it came to carrying out deportations was a lack of documentation. "In order to organize someone's return, the person needs to be recognized as a national by the authorities of the corresponding country, and a lot of the time that is not so simple."

When dealing with someone without a passport, authorities first have to investigate where they are from and persuade a state to issue documentation for the person in question, or issue permission for them to travel there.

These procedures are complex and take time. The fact that almost half of CIE inmates end up not being deported has nothing to do with a lack of diligence on the part of the authorities, but - say NGOs and the CGAE - the treatment of people who, on the whole, should not be deprived of their freedom without guarantees that they can be deported.

"It is necessary for judges to examine in detail the possibility that, in practice, repatriation is viable," said Aitor Esteban, the Basque parliamentary group spokesman for the Congress Interior Committee.

"Internment ought to be an exceptional measure," says the Catalan parliamentary group spokesman for the committee, Antoni Picó i Azanza. "If 50 percent are not expelled, we have a problem."

The question of whether it is necessary and proportionate to resort to forced internment is particularly relevant as the government finalizes a new law to regulate the operation of the CIEs. The new law will not address the issue in any detail, but the secretary of state for security says it is priority to clearly establish the requirements for entrance into a CIE and ensure police have orders only to request internment for those who fulfill the conditions to be effectively deported.

The report presented on Tuesday by the CGAE also made reference to the question. "Internment is the last measure available to member states, according to the 2008 European directive on the return of nationals of third countries in irregular situations," explained Pascual Aguelo, president of CGAE's immigration subcommittee. "It can only apply to the last stage of preparing a return or carrying out the deportation process. And the disappearance of a reasonable perspective on deportation implies a loss of justification for the measure."

The CGAE believes Spain has not properly incorporated this directive, which has led to a lack of protection for imprisoned immigrants.

 

Para poder comentar debes estar registrado en Eskup y haber iniciado sesión

Darse de alta ¿Por qué darse de alta?

Otras noticias

El Gordo

13437

2º Premio

92845

3º Premio

07637

4º Premio

  • 07617
  • 67009

5º Premio

  • 46984
  • 32306
  • 98538
  • 74012
  • 91363
  • 60090
  • 67924
  • 52028

Comprueba tu número

Buscador y PDF con la lista oficial.

Patrocinio

OpenbankAdvertisement

Últimas noticias

Ver todo el día

Mexico admite la participación de la Policía en matanzas de inmigrantes

En agosto de 2010, 72 centroamericanos fueron hallados sin vida en San Fernado (Tamaulipas) En abril de 2011, 193 personas más

De pobres a empresarios del reciclaje de basura

Cuatro millones de latinoamericanos trabajan separando desperdicios en los vertederos y un 75% lo hace de forma insalubre

El rescate de un banco aviva el temor a una crisis en Rusia

Moscú planea medidas para limitar las exportaciones de grano

Samarás cede para sacar adelante a su candidato a presidente de Grecia

El primer ministro griego ofrece incluir en el Gobierno a "independientes proeuropeos"

LATIN AMERICA

Ballet diplomacy

Roger Salas Madrid

Dancers and choreographers have been persecuted and ostracized under Cuba’s Castro regime

Cubans in Havana greet US deal with joy and skepticism

Locals celebrate liberation of their most symbolic prisoners and await improvements

Identity of mysterious US spy released by Havana revealed

American news outlets point to Rolando Sarraff Trujillo, a native Cuban with relatives in Spain

US and Cuba to start talks to normalize relations

Announcement from White House comes after news that US contractor Alan Gross has been freed by Havana

Lo más visto en...

» Top 50

Webs de PRISA

cerrar ventana